What is the purpose of evaluating award recommendations according to the Navy and Marine Corps Awards manual?

Evaluating award recommendations serves the essential purpose of determining the appropriateness of an award. This process is crucial in ensuring that the recognition given to service members accurately reflects their actions, contributions, and the circumstances surrounding those actions. The evaluation considers factors such as the significance of the achievement, the impact on the mission, and how the actions align with the criteria established for specific awards.

This careful assessment helps maintain the integrity of the awarding process, ensuring that awards are reserved for deserving individuals who meet the established standards. By focusing on appropriateness, the evaluation helps prevent any dilution of the significance of awards within the Navy and Marine Corps and supports a culture of meritocracy and accountability in recognizing exemplary service.